Most share of freehold problems come down to three things: money, decisions and paperwork. One owner stops paying their share of the costs, the owners cannot agree on works, or the company that owns the freehold has not been looked after and something goes wrong when a flat is sold. The law gives a leaseholder-owned freehold company the same tools as any other landlord to recover service charges, and company law gives shareholders remedies when the people running a company act unfairly, but those routes are slow and expensive between neighbours. Most share of freehold disputes can be prevented by getting the structure right early. Where they cannot, our property disputes team can help you find the quickest workable way out.
This guide covers the problems we see most often, what the law says about each, and the practical steps that stop a disagreement becoming a “share of freehold nightmare”.
Why share of freehold disputes happen
When leaseholders buy their freehold, they become their own landlord. If you need a refresher on how that works, see our guide to what a share of freehold is. The structure has some built-in pressure points:
- **Your neighbour is your landlord.** Every decision about the building is also a decision about the people you share a staircase with.
- **The directors are volunteers.** They are usually flat owners with full-time jobs, and many have never run a company before.
- **The old leases stay in place.** Leases often pre-date the freehold purchase and were written for a relationship with an outside landlord. Their repair and service charge clauses may not suit a self-managed building.
- **Small buildings have no tie-breaker.** In a two-flat conversion with a 50/50 split, any disagreement is a deadlock.
The most common share of freehold problems
An owner who will not pay
This is the problem we are asked about most. One owner refuses or simply fails to pay their share of insurance, repairs or a major works bill, and the others are left covering the shortfall.
The freehold company, as landlord, can recover service charges in the same way as any landlord, provided the lease allows the cost to be recovered and the company follows the statutory rules. In particular:
- the demand must include the landlord’s name and address (sections 47 and 48 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987), or the sums are not treated as due;
- a demand must be accompanied by the prescribed summary of tenants’ rights and obligations (section 21B of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985);
- costs generally cannot be recovered if they were incurred more than 18 months before the leaseholder was told about them (section 20B of the 1985 Act); and
- where any leaseholder’s share of works would exceed £250, the section 20 consultation process must be followed first, or recovery is capped at £250 per flat unless the tribunal grants dispensation.
If the paperwork is in order, the company can bring a debt claim in the county court or ask the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) to determine that the charges are payable under section 27A of the 1985 Act. Forfeiture of the lease for unpaid service charges is heavily restricted: the amount must first be agreed or finally determined (section 81 of the Housing Act 1996). The Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill, introduced to Parliament on 19 November 2026, proposes replacing forfeiture with a new court-led enforcement scheme, so this area is likely to change.
What the other owners usually cannot do is withhold services, cut off the defaulting owner or force them to give up their share in the company. Their share is normally tied to their flat.
Deadlock
Where two owners each hold 50% of the company and each is a director, neither can outvote the other. Under the model articles that many small companies adopt, the chair has a casting vote at board meetings, but that rarely helps in a two-person building, and many bespoke articles remove it.
In larger buildings, deadlock takes a different form: a minority of owners refuses to approve spending, or the owners are split over whether to appoint a managing agent. Ordinary decisions of the shareholders need a simple majority and some decisions, such as changing the articles, need 75% (sections 282 and 283 of the Companies Act 2006).
The answer to deadlock is almost always contractual. Articles of association, or a separate members’ agreement, can provide for an independent expert to decide disputes about repairs, an obligation to mediate, or a mechanism for appointing a professional managing agent if the owners cannot agree.
Directors acting without the others
The opposite problem arises when one or two energetic owners take control, commission works, choose contractors or appoint agents without consulting anyone. Directors owe their duties to the company, including the duty to act within their powers, to promote the success of the company and to avoid conflicts of interest (sections 171 to 177 of the Companies Act 2006). A director who instructs a relative’s firm without declaring the interest, for example, may be in breach.
Shareholders can remove a director by ordinary resolution (section 168 of the Companies Act 2006). Where the company’s affairs are being run in a way that is unfairly prejudicial to some members, those members can petition the court under section 994. Both are serious steps between neighbours, and an unfair prejudice petition is expensive. In practice, a properly minuted meeting and clear written rules on spending limits usually resolve the issue earlier.
Major works and the reserve fund
Disagreements about whether, when and how to carry out major works are the most expensive disputes we see. One owner wants the roof replaced now; another is planning to sell and does not want to pay. The section 20 consultation rules apply to a leaseholder-owned company in the same way as to any other landlord, and skipping them because “we all know each other” is one of the most common mistakes. Building up a reserve fund, if the leases allow it, takes the sting out of large one-off bills.
Lease extensions on unequal terms
Owners often extend their leases to 999 years after buying the freehold, but problems arise if some owners extend and others do not, or if the terms differ. Leaseholders who did not take part in the freehold purchase keep their statutory right to a lease extension and can insist on a premium calculated under the statutory formula rather than a nominal sum. Agreeing a consistent policy early avoids resentment later. We cover this in more detail in our guide to extending a lease with a share of the freehold.
Administration failures
Missed confirmation statements and accounts lead Companies House to strike companies off the register. When a company is dissolved, its property, including the freehold of your building, passes to the Crown as bona vacantia (section 1012 of the Companies Act 2006). The company can usually be restored, but it takes time and cost, and it often surfaces at the worst moment: when a flat is being sold and the buyer’s solicitor checks the register.
Other administration problems include lapsed buildings insurance, share certificates that were never issued or have been lost, and sales completed without the seller’s share being transferred, leaving a former owner as a member.
Freehold held in personal names
Where the freehold is registered in the owners’ personal names rather than a company, every sale means changing the names on the freehold title, and a death or a former owner who has moved abroad can stall the process. Moving the freehold into a company is often worth doing for this reason alone.
Alterations and breaches by one owner
Disputes also arise when one owner carries out works, lets the flat on short lets or keeps pets in breach of the lease. The company, as landlord, has the same rights to enforce the lease as any other landlord, but the other owners must agree to take action, and the owner in breach is also a shareholder. See our guide to licences for alterations for how consent for works should be handled.
How to avoid share of freehold disputes
| Step | Why it helps |
|---|---|
| Use a company rather than personal names | Sales become a simple share transfer, and the structure survives deaths and departures |
| Adopt bespoke articles of association | Tie shares to flats, set voting rules, deal with deadlock and director appointments |
| Consider a members’ agreement | Records how decisions are made, spending limits and how disputes are resolved |
| Vary the leases after the freehold purchase | Extend terms consistently, remove ground rent and update repair, insurance and reserve fund clauses |
| Follow service charge rules strictly | Proper demands and section 20 consultation make sums recoverable if an owner refuses to pay |
| Build a reserve fund | Avoids large one-off bills that trigger disputes |
| Diarise Companies House deadlines | Prevents strike-off and the loss of the freehold to the Crown |
| Hold an annual meeting and keep minutes | Creates a record of what was agreed and keeps everyone informed |
| Appoint a managing agent if the owners cannot cope | Takes day-to-day decisions out of neighbour relationships |
Many of these are part of running the company well from day one, which we cover in our guide to running a freehold company after you buy the freehold. If you are buying a share of freehold flat, the same points are worth checking before you exchange, as we explain in our comparison of share of freehold and leasehold.
When a dispute has already started
If you are already in a dispute with your co-owners, a measured approach usually produces the best result.
- **Read the documents.** Check what the leases and the articles actually say about repairs, service charges, voting and director appointments.
- **Put it in writing.** Set out the issue and what you are asking for. If money is owed, make sure any demand complies with the statutory requirements above.
- **Call a meeting.** A properly convened board or general meeting, with minutes, often clears the air and produces a decision that binds everyone.
- **Try mediation.** It is quicker and cheaper than litigation, and it preserves the relationships that will continue after the dispute ends.
- **Use the tribunal or court if needed.** Service charge disputes go to the First-tier Tribunal; company disputes and debt claims go to the courts.
Bear in mind that in a leaseholder-owned company, legal costs are often paid from service charges, so every owner, including the one in dispute, ends up funding the company’s side. The tribunal can order that a landlord’s costs are not added to the service charge (section 20C of the 1985 Act). The government has also announced that, from 1 April 2027, landlords will generally need court or tribunal approval to pass legal costs of service charge challenges on to leaseholders, subject to Parliamentary approval of the regulations.
Because Gurve Legal handles both company and property work, we can look at a share of freehold dispute from both angles at once: the lease, the articles and the directors’ duties. We also act for both sides, whether you are the owner being chased or the company doing the chasing.
Frequently asked questions
How does shared freehold work?
In a share of freehold, the flat owners jointly own the freehold of the building, usually through a company in which each holds a share, while each keeps a lease of their own flat. The company is the landlord, so it insures and manages the building under the leases and collects the service charge, with decisions taken by the owners as directors and shareholders. On a sale, the owner usually transfers both the lease and their share in the company.
Is it easy to extend a lease on a share of freehold?
Usually, yes, because the owners can agree the extension among themselves through the freehold company, often for no premium. It still needs a properly drafted deed or new lease, the consent of any mortgage lender and registration at HM Land Registry. Problems arise where the owners cannot agree terms, or where some have already extended on different terms, which is why a consistent policy agreed early helps.
Are share of freehold flats difficult to sell?
Not usually, and many buyers see a share of freehold as an advantage. Sales slow down when the company has been neglected: missing share certificates, overdue Companies House filings, a company that has been struck off, or co-owners who need to sign documents and do not respond. Keeping the company’s records and filings up to date avoids most of these delays.
Talk to us about a share of freehold dispute
If a disagreement with your co-owners is affecting your building or your plans to sell, speak to our property dispute solicitors before positions harden. Where the problem lies in the company’s constitution, our shareholders agreement solicitors can help put better rules in place. Call us on +44 207 566 1188 or email info@gurvelegal.com.


