Leaseholders in England and Wales who are unhappy with their landlord have two statutory routes to take control of their building: the right to manage, which transfers management to a company the leaseholders run, and collective enfranchisement, which lets them buy the freehold outright. Neither requires the landlord’s agreement or proof of bad management, but they differ sharply in cost, timescale, the number of leaseholders needed and what you end up with.
This guide compares the two side by side as the law stands on 20 November 2026, sets out the pros and cons of each and explains how to decide which suits your building. If your group is ready to talk it through, our collective enfranchisement solicitors advise on both routes and can check your building’s eligibility for each.

The short answer
Right to manage gives you control of how the building is run, quickly and at relatively low cost, but the landlord keeps the freehold, the ground rent and the leases stay exactly as they are. Buying the freehold costs considerably more and takes longer, but it gives you ownership: no outside landlord, no ground rent to a third party, and the ability to grant yourselves long lease extensions. Many buildings choose right to manage when the problem is poor management and money is tight, and enfranchisement when the leases are getting shorter or the group wants a permanent solution.
Right to manage vs collective enfranchisement at a glance
| Right to manage | Collective enfranchisement | |
|---|---|---|
| Legislation | Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002, Part 2, Chapter 1 | Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993, Part 1, Chapter 1 |
| What you get | Management of the building | Ownership of the freehold (and management with it) |
| Price paid to landlord | None | Market value of the freehold under the statutory formula, including marriage value for leases of 80 years or less |
| Landlord’s costs | Not payable in most cases since 3 March 2025 | Participating leaseholders pay the landlord’s reasonable legal and valuation costs |
| Minimum flats | At least two flats held by qualifying tenants, making up two-thirds of the flats | At least two flats held by qualifying tenants, making up two-thirds of the flats |
| Support needed | Members holding at least half of the flats | Qualifying tenants of at least half of the flats must give the notice |
| Commercial space limit | Up to 50% of internal floor area | Up to 25% of internal floor area |
| Vehicle | RTM company limited by guarantee | Nominee purchaser, usually a company owned by the participants |
| Typical timescale | About four months from claim notice if undisputed | Commonly six to twelve months or more, longer if the price goes to the tribunal |
| Ground rent | Still paid to the landlord | Paid to your own company, and can be removed when leases are extended |
| Lease extensions afterwards | Still negotiated with, and paid to, the landlord | Granted by your own company on terms the owners agree |
For a full walk-through of each route, see our guide to the right to manage and how to buy the freehold of your building.
Right to manage: pros and cons
Advantages
- No purchase price. The landlord receives nothing for the loss of management, so the cost is limited to the RTM company’s own legal and set-up costs.
- Cheaper to run a claim. Since section 50 of the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 came into force on 3 March 2025, the RTM company is generally no longer liable for the landlord’s costs of the claim. Before that date, the landlord’s costs were a significant deterrent.
- Wider eligibility. Mixed-use buildings with up to 50% commercial floor space can now qualify, which brings in many London blocks above shops and restaurants that cannot (yet) be enfranchised.
- Speed. An undisputed claim can complete about four months after the claim notice.
- Less financial commitment from each leaseholder. Nobody has to raise a share of a purchase price, so it is easier to get half the building to sign up.
Disadvantages
- No ownership. The landlord still owns the freehold, collects ground rent and can sell its interest to someone else.
- No help with short leases. Each leaseholder still has to extend their lease with the landlord and pay a premium, including marriage value if the lease has 80 years or less to run.
- The landlord keeps some powers. Forfeiture stays with the landlord, and the RTM company must notify the landlord before giving approvals such as consent to assign or carry out alterations.
- Responsibility without ownership. Volunteer directors take on the landlord’s management obligations, including service charge accounting, insurance and building safety duties, without the long-term security of owning the building.
Collective enfranchisement: pros and cons
Advantages
- Permanent control. The leaseholders’ company owns the freehold, so there is no outside landlord to deal with in future.
- Cheaper lease extensions afterwards. Once you own the freehold, your company can grant each participating leaseholder a long lease extension (often 999 years at a peppercorn rent) without paying a premium to a third party. This is usually the single biggest financial benefit.
- Ground rent ends up in your hands. Ground rent is paid to your own company and can be removed altogether when leases are varied or extended.
- Value. Flats in buildings where the leaseholders own the freehold (often marketed as “share of freehold”) tend to be more attractive to buyers and lenders.
Disadvantages
- The price. The leaseholders must pay the value of the freehold under the statutory formula in Schedule 6 to the 1993 Act. Where leases have 80 years or less to run, that includes a share of marriage value, which the 2024 Act’s reforms would abolish but which is still payable today because those provisions are not in force.
- The landlord’s costs. Participating leaseholders pay the landlord’s reasonable legal and valuation costs as well as their own.
- Stricter eligibility. The commercial floor space limit for enfranchisement is still 25%. The 2024 Act would raise it to 50%, but that provision (section 29) has not been brought into force.
- Time and coordination. The participants need a binding agreement between themselves covering contributions, decision-making and what happens if someone drops out or sells. Disputes over the price can go to the First-tier Tribunal, adding months.
Cost is usually the deciding factor. We break down the price and the professional fees in how much it costs to buy the freehold of your flat.
Is right to manage a good idea for your building?
It depends on what the problem actually is. These are the questions we ask leaseholder groups at the first meeting.
- What are you trying to fix? If the complaint is poor maintenance, an unresponsive managing agent or service charges that feel out of control, right to manage addresses that directly. If the concern is the length of the leases, ground rent or the landlord’s ability to profit from the building, only owning the freehold solves it.
- How long are the leases? Where several leases are approaching 80 years, buying the freehold before they drop below it avoids marriage value, and the group can then extend its own leases. Where leases are long, the urgency is lower and right to manage may be enough.
- Does the building qualify for both? A building with between 25% and 50% commercial floor space can currently use right to manage but not collective enfranchisement.
- Can enough leaseholders fund a purchase? Enfranchisement only works if at least half the flats are willing and able to contribute to the price and costs. Right to manage needs the same level of support, but far less money.
- How cooperative is the group? Both routes need people prepared to act as directors. Enfranchisement also needs a robust participation agreement, because the commitment is larger and lasts longer.
Can you do both?
Yes. Exercising the right to manage does not stop the leaseholders buying the freehold later, and many buildings use right to manage first to take control of the service charge and repairs, then enfranchise once funds are in place or as leases shorten. If you buy the freehold, the right to manage becomes unnecessary because your company is the landlord. It is worth planning both together where possible, so that the RTM company and any future freehold company are structured sensibly and leaseholders are not paying for two sets of set-up costs without a reason.
How reform could change the calculation
Two sets of changes are relevant to the choice, and neither should be treated as certain until it is in force.
- The Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024. Its right to manage reforms are already in force. Its enfranchisement valuation reforms, including the abolition of marriage value and the new valuation scheme, are not. There is no confirmed commencement date.
- The Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill. Introduced to Parliament on 19 November 2026, it proposes, among other things, a £250 cap on ground rents in existing leases, an easier route for existing blocks to convert to commonhold with 50% support, and a cheaper way for leaseholders to take control of their building. These are proposals, not law, and may change in Parliament.
Waiting for reform can make sense for some groups, but it carries its own risk: leases keep shortening while Parliament debates, and a lease that drops below 80 years attracts marriage value under the current rules. That trade-off needs looking at building by building, with up-to-date valuation advice.
What both routes have in common
- Both are “no fault” rights: the landlord cannot refuse if the building qualifies and the procedure is followed.
- Both are procedurally strict. Defective notices are the most common reason claims fail.
- Both need a company, directors and clear agreement between the participating leaseholders.
- Both can be challenged by the landlord in the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber).
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an RMC and an RTM company?
A resident management company (RMC) is usually set up when the building is developed and is named in the leases, so its management role comes from the leases themselves. A right to manage (RTM) company is formed by the leaseholders later to take over management from the landlord under Chapter 1 of Part 2 of the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002, without needing the landlord’s agreement. Managing the building does not make either company the freeholder, although some RMCs also hold the freehold because of how the development was set up.
Can a right to manage company buy the freehold?
Not as part of the right to manage: an RTM company takes over management functions only, and its articles must state that acquiring and exercising the right to manage is its object. Buying the freehold is a separate collective enfranchisement claim by the qualifying leaseholders, usually through a company formed for the purchase. The same leaseholders can do both, and many buildings use right to manage first and buy the freehold later.
Next steps
The right choice depends on your building, your leases and your group, and the decision is easier with the numbers in front of you: an indication of the freehold price from a specialist valuer, the lease lengths across the building and a clear view of whether the building qualifies for each route. Individual leaseholders who are not part of a group action can still extend their own lease, and our lease extension solicitors handle those claims too. We act for leaseholder groups and for freeholders, so we understand both sides of these claims.
If your building is weighing up right to manage against buying the freehold, our collective enfranchisement and right to manage solicitors can review your position. Call us on +44 207 566 1188 or email info@gurvelegal.com.


