Once a leaseholder has served a section 42 notice, the landlord must reply with a counter-notice under section 45 of the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993 by the date given in the notice. What the counter-notice says, and whether it arrives on time, decides what happens next: negotiation, an application to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber), or a county court application. Both sides face strict deadlines, and missing one can end the claim or hand the other side a significant advantage. Our lease extension solicitors manage this stage for leaseholders and for landlords.
This guide explains the counter-notice, the negotiation window, tribunal applications and what happens when either side misses a deadline, as the law stands in November 2026. It applies to flats in England and Wales.
What a section 45 counter-notice must say
The counter-notice must be given by the date specified in the tenant’s notice, which must be at least two months after the tenant’s notice was served. Under section 45(2) it must do one of three things:
- Admit that the tenant had the right to a new lease on the date the notice was served.
- Not admit the right, giving reasons. For example, the landlord may say the lease does not qualify or the notice is invalid.
- Admit or not admit, and say the landlord intends to apply to the court on redevelopment grounds under section 47.
If the counter-notice admits the right, section 45(3) requires it to state which of the tenant’s proposals are accepted and which are not, and to give counter-proposals on the ones that are not, typically a higher premium and some changes to the proposed lease terms. The counter-notice must also give an address in England and Wales where notices can be served on the landlord.
An admission binds the landlord on whether you had the right to a new lease, unless the landlord was misled. It does not commit the landlord to your proposed premium. If you have not yet served your notice, our guide to serving a section 42 notice explains how to set up the claim properly.
If the counter-notice admits the right: negotiation
Where the counter-notice admits the right, the two valuers then negotiate the premium and the solicitors negotiate the lease terms. The 1993 Act sets the timetable under section 48:
| Stage | Time limit |
|---|---|
| Earliest date either side can apply to the tribunal | 2 months after the counter-notice was given |
| Latest date for a tribunal application | 6 months after the counter-notice was given |
| Completing the new lease once all terms are agreed | 2 months from the date terms are agreed |
| Completing the new lease after a tribunal decision | 2 months from the date the decision becomes final, or another period the tribunal sets |
| Applying to court if the new lease is not completed | Within 2 months after the completion period ends |
Within that window, most of the work is valuation. The landlord’s counter-proposal will normally be supported by its own valuer’s figures, and the gap between the two valuations is what is negotiated. Points often in dispute include the relative value of the existing lease, the deferment rate, the value of the flat with a long lease and, where the lease has 80 years or less to run, marriage value.
Applying to the First-tier Tribunal
If terms are not agreed, either side can apply to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) to determine them, once two months have passed since the counter-notice and before six months have passed. Applying does not stop negotiations; the parties can continue to talk and settle at any stage. The tribunal then gives directions for each side’s valuation evidence and any disputed lease terms, and decides the points that remain at a hearing or on the papers.
Each side generally bears its own costs of the tribunal proceedings, and the leaseholder is not liable under section 60 for the landlord’s costs of those proceedings. The tribunal can make costs orders where a party has behaved unreasonably. Our guide to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) explains how applications, directions and hearings work in leasehold cases.
Missed deadlines: the leaseholder’s side
The most expensive mistake a leaseholder can make at this stage is letting the six-month deadline pass. If terms have not been agreed and no tribunal application is made within six months of the counter-notice, the tenant’s notice is treated as withdrawn under section 53. The consequences are:
- the valuation date secured by the original notice is lost;
- the leaseholder remains liable for the landlord’s reasonable costs incurred up to that point under section 60;
- under section 42(7) no new notice can be served for the same flat for 12 months. Section 28 of the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 will remove this bar, but it is not yet in force;
- the lease is a year or more shorter by the time a new claim can be made, which can push it below 80 years and bring marriage value into play.
A similar trap applies at the end. Once terms are agreed or determined, the new lease must be completed within the two-month appropriate period, or a court application made within the following two months. If neither happens, the notice is again treated as withdrawn. Where negotiations are dragging close to the six-month point, making a protective tribunal application is usually the safer course.
Missed deadlines: the landlord’s side
Landlords face equally strict consequences. If the landlord does not give a counter-notice by the date in the tenant’s notice, section 49 allows the leaseholder to apply to the county court, within six months of the date by which the counter-notice should have been given, for an order setting the terms of the new lease in line with the leaseholder’s own proposals. That includes the premium proposed in the tenant’s notice. In practice, a missed counter-notice can cost a landlord a large part of the premium it might otherwise have negotiated.
The leaseholder also has to act. If the leaseholder does not apply to the court within the six-month window, the notice is treated as withdrawn, with the same consequences described above. Leaseholders who receive no counter-notice should not assume the claim will resolve itself.
For landlords, the practical lessons are to diarise the counter-notice date as soon as a section 42 notice arrives, to instruct a valuer immediately, and to make sure the counter-notice contains genuine counter-proposals and a valid address for service.
If the counter-notice does not admit the right
Where the landlord’s counter-notice disputes the right to a new lease, the landlord must, if it wants to pursue the challenge, apply to the county court under section 46 for a declaration that the tenant had no right, within two months of giving the counter-notice. If the landlord does not apply in time, or withdraws its application, the claim proceeds under section 49 as if no counter-notice had been given, so the leaseholder can apply for the terms to be set on the basis of its own proposals.
If the court dismisses the landlord’s application, it declares the counter-notice of no effect and orders the landlord to give a further counter-notice by a date it sets. That further counter-notice must then deal with the leaseholder’s proposals, and the negotiation and tribunal timetable runs from it.
The redevelopment ground
Section 47 lets a landlord ask the court to defeat a lease extension claim on redevelopment grounds. The court must be satisfied that the existing lease is due to end within five years of the date the tenant’s notice was served, that the landlord intends to demolish, reconstruct or carry out substantial works to the whole or a substantial part of the premises once it ends, and that it could not reasonably do so without getting possession of the flat. The landlord must apply within two months of the counter-notice. This ground is rarely relevant unless the lease is very short.
Which deadlines to diarise
- The counter-notice date stated in the section 42 notice.
- Two months after the counter-notice: the landlord’s deadline to apply to court on a non-admission or redevelopment counter-notice, and the earliest tribunal application date.
- Six months after the counter-notice: the last day for a tribunal application.
- Six months after the date a counter-notice was due, if none was given: the leaseholder’s deadline for a county court application.
- Two months after terms are agreed or determined: the completion deadline, followed by a further two months to apply to court.
The full timeline, from preparation to registration of the new lease, is set out in our guide to the lease extension process step by step.
Frequently asked questions
Can the landlord inspect the flat after a section 42 notice?
Yes. Once the section 42 notice has been given, section 44 of the 1993 Act gives the landlord, and anyone authorised to act for it, access to the flat at any reasonable time so that it can value its interest. The landlord must give the leaseholder at least three days’ notice.
Who has to serve the counter-notice?
The landlord gives the counter-notice to the leaseholder under section 45(1) of the 1993 Act, by the date stated in the section 42 notice. Where there are intermediate landlords, the competent landlord identified under section 40, broadly the landlord whose interest is long enough to grant the new lease, conducts the claim on behalf of all the other landlords.
Can I withdraw my lease extension claim after the counter-notice?
Yes. Under section 52 of the 1993 Act, the leaseholder can withdraw the notice at any time before the new lease is entered into, by giving notice to the landlord and the other parties entitled to it. The leaseholder remains liable for the landlord’s reasonable costs incurred up to the withdrawal, and under section 42(7) cannot serve a new notice for the same flat for 12 months while that bar remains in force.
Acting for either side
The counter-notice stage is where lease extension claims are most often won or lost on procedure rather than value. We act for leaseholders pursuing claims and for landlords and freehold companies responding to them, so we see how each side uses the timetable. If you have received a counter-notice, are waiting for one, or have received a section 42 notice as a landlord, speak to our lease extension solicitors about the next steps. Where a dispute goes beyond the lease extension itself, our property litigation team can help. Call us on +44 207 566 1188 or email info@gurvelegal.com.


