The leasehold valuation tribunal no longer exists. On 1 July 2013 its work in England passed to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber), and it is that tribunal, through its Residential Property division, that now decides leasehold disputes over service charges, major works, lease extension and freehold prices, the right to manage, lease variations and much more. Many leaseholders, landlords and even some professionals still use the old name, and many leases and older guides still refer to it.

This guide explains what the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) does, what it cannot do, how an application works, what it costs and how decisions can be appealed. Where a dispute is already under way, our leasehold disputes team acts for leaseholders and landlords in the tribunal and the courts.

Leaseholder preparing papers for a tribunal application at home

From the leasehold valuation tribunal to the Property Chamber

Before July 2013, residential leasehold disputes in England were heard by leasehold valuation tribunals run by the Residential Property Tribunal Service. The Transfer of Tribunal Functions Order 2013 moved those functions, along with those of the rent assessment committees, the agricultural land tribunals and the Adjudicator to HM Land Registry, into a single First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber), which came into existence on 1 July 2013. Leasehold cases are handled by its Residential Property division, which operates through regional offices covering London, the Eastern region, the Midlands, the North and the South.

Two practical points follow. First, any statutory reference to “the leasehold valuation tribunal” in an older lease or document now means the First-tier Tribunal in England. Second, the position in Wales is different: Welsh leasehold disputes go to the Residential Property Tribunal for Wales, which kept the leasehold valuation tribunal jurisdiction. The rest of this guide deals with the tribunal in England.

What the tribunal decides

The tribunal’s leasehold jurisdiction comes from a series of Acts, chiefly the Landlord and Tenant Acts 1985 and 1987, the Leasehold Reform Act 1967, the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993 and the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002. The most common applications are set out below.

Type of disputeWhat the tribunal can doMain statutory basis
Service chargesDecide whether a charge is payable, by whom, how much and when, for past or proposed costsLandlord and Tenant Act 1985, s.27A
Major works consultationGrant or refuse dispensation from the section 20 consultation requirementsLandlord and Tenant Act 1985, s.20ZA
Administration chargesDecide whether fees such as consent fees, arrears charges and legal costs under the lease are payable and reasonableCommonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002, Sch 11
Breach of leaseDetermine whether a leaseholder has breached a covenant, which a landlord usually needs before it can start forfeitureCommonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002, s.168
Lease extensions and freehold purchasesDecide the premium, the price and disputed terms where the parties cannot agreeLeasehold Reform Act 1967; 1993 Act, ss.24 and 48
Right to manageDecide whether an RTM company is entitled to acquire management, and some disputes after it hasCommonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002, s.84
Defective leasesOrder a variation where a lease fails to make satisfactory provision for repairs, insurance or service chargesLandlord and Tenant Act 1987, ss.35 to 39
Failing managementAppoint a manager to take over from the landlordLandlord and Tenant Act 1987, s.24

The service charge jurisdiction is by far the busiest. We explain the grounds for a challenge in our guide to challenging service charges, and the consultation rules for large projects in section 20 consultation for major works.

Several other areas feed into the tribunal in less obvious ways:

  • Forfeiture. Before a landlord can serve a section 146 notice for most breaches of a residential long lease, the breach must be admitted or determined, often by the tribunal, and service charge arrears must usually be agreed or determined first. We cover the wider process in forfeiture and section 146 notices.
  • Lease extension disputes. If the landlord serves a counter-notice and terms cannot be agreed, the leaseholder must apply to the tribunal within strict time limits or the claim is treated as withdrawn. See after the section 42 notice: counter-notices, negotiation and the tribunal, or speak to our lease extension solicitors before the deadline passes.
  • Varying a lease. Where the leaseholders and landlord cannot agree a change by deed, the statutory variation grounds may allow the tribunal to order one. Our guide to a deed of variation explains when each route applies.
  • Consent fees. The tribunal does not decide whether a landlord should give consent to works, but the fee charged for granting it, for example for a licence for alterations, is an administration charge that it can review for reasonableness.
  • Freehold estate charges. Owners of freehold houses on private estates have far fewer rights than leaseholders under current law, although reform is planned. We look at where they stand today in estate management charges on freehold homes.

What the tribunal cannot do

The tribunal is a specialist body with limits. It generally cannot:

  • award damages, for example for disrepair, leaks or loss of use, which are county court claims;
  • make a possession order or forfeit a lease;
  • enforce payment of a debt: once it has decided what is payable, recovery is through the county court;
  • rule on a matter the leaseholder has already agreed or admitted, or that a court or arbitrator has already decided. Simply paying a charge does not count as agreeing to it, which is an important protection under section 27A(5) of the 1985 Act.

Because claims often involve both, the county court can transfer the leasehold questions in a debt claim to the tribunal, and tribunal judges can also sit as county court judges so that both sets of issues are decided together. Since 3 March 2025, where the First-tier Tribunal has jurisdiction, parties can no longer start those matters in the High Court instead.

How an application works

  1. Try to resolve it first. The tribunal expects parties to have engaged before applying. A clear written request for information or a breakdown of disputed charges often narrows the issues or settles them.
  2. Choose the right application. Each type of case has its own form and statutory basis, available on gov.uk. Using the wrong one causes delay.
  3. Apply and pay the fee. Many applications can be made online or by email to the regional office. A hearing fee is payable later if the case goes to a hearing.
  4. Directions. A procedural judge issues directions setting out what each side must provide and by when: usually a statement of case, a schedule of the disputed items (often called a Scott schedule), documents and witness statements, then a hearing bundle.
  5. Paper or hearing. Straightforward cases can be decided on the papers if the parties agree. Others have a hearing, in person or by video, and the tribunal may inspect the building.
  6. Decision. The tribunal issues a written decision with reasons, typically some weeks after the hearing.

Panels usually combine a legally qualified judge with a surveyor or other expert member, which is why the tribunal is well suited to arguments about the standard and cost of works or the valuation of a lease.

Fees and costs

Tribunal fees are modest compared with court fees. Following the government’s court and tribunal fee update from 13 July 2026, the application fee for a service charge or administration charge determination is £114, with a £227 hearing fee if the case is heard. Other application types carry different fees. Help with fees is available for those who qualify, and the tribunal can order the other party to reimburse fees paid by the successful side. Always check the current fee on the relevant gov.uk form before applying.

The bigger question is legal costs. The general rule in the tribunal is that each party bears its own costs. The tribunal can order costs against a party who has behaved unreasonably in bringing, defending or conducting the case, but the threshold is high. That makes the tribunal accessible, but it also means a leaseholder who wins will often not recover their legal fees from the landlord.

The flip side is the landlord’s costs. Many leases allow the landlord to recover its legal costs through the service charge or directly from the leaseholder as an administration charge. Leaseholders can ask the tribunal for:

  • a section 20C order under the 1985 Act, preventing the landlord from adding its costs of the proceedings to the service charge; and
  • an order under paragraph 5A of Schedule 11 to the 2002 Act, reducing or extinguishing a leaseholder’s liability to pay the landlord’s litigation costs as an administration charge.

These protections are being strengthened. Under regulations laid in November 2026, from 1 April 2027 landlords will need court or tribunal approval before passing their legal costs on to leaseholders, and leaseholders will gain a new right to recover their own legal costs. Further regulations explaining how this will work are due before the end of 2026.

Appealing a decision

Appeals go to the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber), but only with permission and only on a point of law. The first step is to ask the First-tier Tribunal itself for permission to appeal, within 28 days of the date it sent its written reasons. If it refuses, the application can be renewed directly to the Upper Tribunal. A disagreement with how the tribunal weighed the evidence is rarely enough: there needs to be an error of law, a wrong approach to valuation principles or a decision no reasonable tribunal could have reached.

Preparing a strong case

  • Read the lease first. Almost every leasehold dispute turns on what the lease actually says about what can be charged, how and when.
  • Use your statutory information rights. Ask for a summary of costs and the supporting invoices before applying, so the application targets the right items.
  • Be specific. The tribunal decides item by item. Vague complaints about high charges rarely succeed without evidence of what a reasonable cost would have been, such as alternative quotes.
  • Keep to the directions. Missing deadlines can lead to evidence being excluded or, at worst, the case being struck out, and it can expose a party to a costs order.
  • Consider group applications. Where a charge affects the whole building, a joint application by several leaseholders shares the work and cost and avoids inconsistent decisions.

Frequently asked questions

Is the leasehold valuation tribunal the same as the First-tier Tribunal?

In England, yes in substance. The leasehold valuation tribunal’s functions were transferred to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) on 1 July 2013. In Wales, leasehold cases go to the Residential Property Tribunal for Wales.

Do I need a solicitor to apply?

No. The tribunal is designed so that parties can represent themselves, and many do. Professional help is most valuable where the sums are large, the lease is complex, the case involves valuation evidence or the other side is represented.

Can landlords use the tribunal too?

Yes. Landlords and management companies regularly apply for determinations that service charges are payable, for dispensation from consultation, or for a finding of breach before taking enforcement action.

How long does a case take?

It varies by region, type of case and complexity. Simple paper determinations can be quicker; contested hearings with expert evidence commonly take many months from application to decision.

How much does it cost to take a landlord to the tribunal?

For a service charge or administration charge application, the tribunal fee is £114, with a further £227 hearing fee if the case goes to a hearing, following the fee changes from 13 July 2026. Other leasehold applications carry different fees, and help with fees is available if you qualify. Each side normally pays its own legal costs, so your own representation is usually the larger expense.

What is the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber)?

It is the specialist tribunal that decides residential property disputes in England, including leasehold disputes. In leasehold cases it determines matters such as service charges, lease extension and enfranchisement terms and the appointment of managers, usually with a panel combining a judge and a surveyor or other expert. It took over the work of the leasehold valuation tribunal on 1 July 2013.

Next steps

The First-tier Tribunal gives leaseholders a relatively low-cost way to resolve disputes about money and management, but cases are won on preparation: the right application, a clear reading of the lease and specific evidence. We act for both leaseholders and landlords, so we can advise on how a case is likely to look from the other side.

If you are facing a dispute over service charges, major works, a lease extension or a breach of lease, speak to our leasehold disputes solicitors. Call us on +44 207 566 1188 or email info@gurvelegal.com.