Leaseholders in England can challenge a service charge that is not payable under their lease, that was not reasonably incurred, or that pays for work not done to a reasonable standard, by applying to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) under section 27A of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985. Those rights are about to get stronger. Under regulations laid in Parliament in November 2026, from 1 April 2027 leaseholders will be able to demand detailed service charge information, landlords will need court or tribunal approval to pass their legal costs on to leaseholders, and leaseholders will gain a right to recover their own legal costs.

This guide sets out the grounds for challenging a service charge, the information you are entitled to now and from 2027, the practical steps before an application and the risks of simply refusing to pay. If you are already in a service charge dispute, our leasehold disputes team acts for leaseholders and landlords.

Communal hallway of a block of flats paid for through the service charge

What counts as a service charge?

Section 18 of the 1985 Act defines a service charge as an amount payable by the tenant of a dwelling, in addition to rent, for services, repairs, maintenance, improvements, insurance or the landlord’s costs of management, where the amount varies according to the costs incurred. That covers most of what leaseholders in a block of flats pay each year: cleaning, lighting, lifts, gardening, buildings insurance, managing agents’ fees, reserve fund contributions and major works.

Two related charges sit under separate rules. Fixed charges that do not vary with costs fall outside the statutory definition. Administration charges, such as fees for consents, arrears letters or the landlord’s legal costs recoverable under the lease, are governed by Schedule 11 to the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002 and can also be challenged in the tribunal.

The grounds for challenging a service charge

1. The lease does not allow it

The starting point is always the lease. A landlord can only recover costs that the lease clearly permits, in the proportion it sets and at the times it allows. Improvements, legal costs, management fees above an agreed level and reserve fund contributions are frequent areas of dispute because many leases do not cover them, or cover them only in limited terms.

2. The cost was not reasonably incurred

Under section 19 of the 1985 Act, relevant costs count towards a service charge only to the extent they are reasonably incurred, and where they relate to services or works, only if those services or works are of a reasonable standard. The question is whether the landlord’s decision and the amount spent were reasonable, not whether the cheapest option was chosen. Evidence that comparable services were available for much less, that the works were defective, or that the landlord paid for work that was never done is the kind of material that wins these arguments.

3. Advance charges are too high

Where the lease allows the landlord to demand on-account payments before costs are incurred, section 19(2) limits them to a reasonable amount. A budget that is out of line with what the building actually needs can be challenged before the money is spent.

4. Consultation was not carried out

For major works costing any leaseholder more than £250, or long-term agreements costing more than £100 a year each, the landlord must consult under section 20. If it has not done so and the tribunal has not dispensed with the requirements, each leaseholder’s contribution is capped. We explain the process in our guide to section 20 consultation.

5. The 18-month rule

Section 20B of the 1985 Act says a leaseholder is not liable for costs incurred more than 18 months before a demand is served, unless within those 18 months the leaseholder was told in writing that the costs had been incurred and that they would be required to contribute. Late “balancing charges” that arrive years after the year end are a common target.

6. The demand is defective

A service charge demand must be accompanied by the prescribed summary of tenants’ rights and obligations, and a leaseholder may withhold payment until it is (section 21B). Demands must also contain the landlord’s name and address, and the landlord must give an address in England and Wales for service of notices (sections 47 and 48 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987). These defects do not usually wipe out the charge, but they can delay when it becomes payable.

7. Building safety costs

For residential buildings at least 11 metres or five storeys high, the Building Safety Act 2022 limits what landlords can recover from leaseholders with qualifying leases for historical building safety defects, and protects them entirely from the cost of remediating unsafe cladding. Charges for these works need to be checked against those protections.

Your information rights now, and from 2027

A challenge is only as good as the information behind it. Under the current law, leaseholders can ask the landlord for a written summary of the costs making up the service charge and can then inspect the accounts, receipts and other supporting documents. Service charge money paid by leaseholders is also held on trust under section 42 of the 1987 Act, which matters if a landlord or agent becomes insolvent.

The government confirmed on 11 November 2026 that new rights will be phased in under five sets of regulations laid in Parliament the following day, subject to Parliamentary approval:

FromWhat changes
1 April 2027Leaseholders can request information about their service charges, including what they pay for and how the building is managed, maintained, repaired and insured, and can ask about previous years. Landlords need a good reason to refuse. Landlords will need court or tribunal approval to pass their legal costs on to leaseholders, and leaseholders gain a right to recover their own legal costs. Further regulations on the litigation costs changes are due before the end of 2026.
1 November 2027Clearer information on charges for all leaseholders; detailed information on buildings insurance and stronger protection against excessive fees for arranging it; clear information on administration fees. Private landlords must use standardised service charge demand forms and provide financial accounts and annual reports.
1 November 2028Councils and housing associations must provide the standardised demands, accounts and annual reports.

The costs changes are the most significant for disputes. At present, many leases allow landlords to recover their legal costs of a tribunal case from leaseholders, even where the leaseholder wins, unless the tribunal makes an order preventing it. From April 2027, the default shifts in leaseholders’ favour. Leaseholders weighing up a challenge now should take advice on whether timing their application affects how costs will be dealt with.

How to challenge a service charge: step by step

  1. Read the lease and the demand together. Identify exactly which items you dispute and why: not permitted by the lease, unreasonable in amount, poor standard, late, or not consulted on.
  2. Request the supporting information. Ask in writing for a summary of costs and copies of invoices, contracts and the managing agent’s agreement. Keep a record of what you asked for and when.
  3. Raise the dispute in writing. Write to the landlord or managing agent setting out the disputed items and inviting a response. Many disputes narrow or settle at this stage, particularly where an error is clear.
  4. Talk to your neighbours. If a charge affects the whole building, a group challenge is stronger and cheaper per leaseholder, and avoids inconsistent outcomes.
  5. Gather evidence of reasonable cost. Alternative quotes, photographs of poor work and expert evidence on the standard of works carry far more weight than a general sense that charges are too high.
  6. Consider mediation. It is often quicker and cheaper than a hearing, and the tribunal encourages it.
  7. Apply to the tribunal. If the dispute cannot be resolved, apply for a determination under section 27A. Ask at the same time for orders preventing the landlord recovering its costs of the proceedings through the service charge (section 20C) or as an administration charge (paragraph 5A of Schedule 11).

The tribunal’s procedure, fees and appeal routes are set out in our guide to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber). At the time of writing, a service charge application carries a £114 application fee and a £227 hearing fee.

Should you stop paying while you dispute the charge?

Usually not. It is tempting to withhold disputed sums, but it carries real risks. The landlord can bring a county court claim for the debt, add interest and administration charges permitted by the lease, contact your mortgage lender, and in some circumstances begin forfeiture proceedings. Statute restricts forfeiture for unpaid service charges: the landlord must first have the amount agreed, admitted or determined by a court or tribunal, and there are minimum thresholds. But a dispute that escalates this way is stressful and expensive.

A safer course is often to pay the undisputed part, and to pay the disputed part “under protest” while you challenge it. Paying does not mean you have accepted the charge: section 27A(5) of the 1985 Act makes clear that a leaseholder is not taken to have agreed or admitted a matter just because they paid it, so you can still apply to the tribunal and recover any overpayment. The exception is where the demand itself is invalid, for example because it lacks the required summary of rights, in which case the sum is not yet payable.

When the problem is the landlord, not the charge

Repeated disputes over service charges are often a symptom of poor management. Leaseholders who are tired of challenging individual items have structural options:

  • Right to manage. Leaseholders of qualifying buildings can take over management through their own company, without proving fault. Since 3 March 2025 the process has been cheaper, and buildings with up to 50% commercial space can qualify. See right to manage explained.
  • Appointment of a manager. Where management has seriously failed, the tribunal can appoint a manager under section 24 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987.
  • Buying the freehold. Collective enfranchisement gives the leaseholders ownership as well as control.

The Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill, introduced on 19 November 2026, also proposes powers to cap excessive permission and administration fees and to replace forfeiture with a new enforcement regime. These remain proposals until the Bill becomes law.

Service charges on commercial premises

The statutory protections above apply to dwellings. Commercial tenants, including medical practices, shops and offices, rely on the terms of their lease and the general law, and disputes are handled differently. Our commercial property litigation team advises on those cases, and we have written about one common example in NHSPS service charge disputes for GP practices.

Frequently asked questions

How far back can I challenge service charges?

There is no fixed statutory cut-off for a tribunal application, but the longer you leave it, the harder it becomes: evidence is lost, and a landlord may argue that you agreed or admitted the charges by your conduct. Raise disputes promptly, ideally when the year-end accounts arrive.

Can my landlord charge me its legal costs if I challenge?

Under the current law, possibly, if the lease allows it, unless the tribunal makes a section 20C or paragraph 5A order. From 1 April 2027, landlords will need court or tribunal approval to pass legal costs on to leaseholders.

Does a challenge affect selling my flat?

An ongoing dispute must be disclosed to buyers and will show up in the leasehold management information their solicitor requests. It does not prevent a sale, but it can affect timing and price, so it is worth resolving where possible.

Can the managing agent’s fees be challenged?

Yes. Management fees are part of the service charge and must be reasonable and permitted by the lease, just like any other cost.

What should I do if I have a dispute with my managing agent?

Raise the complaint in writing with the managing agent first, using its complaints procedure, and copy in the landlord if the agent acts for it. Property management agents in England must belong to a government-approved redress scheme, which can usually investigate complaints about the agent’s service once its own complaints procedure has been used. If the dispute is about whether service charges are payable or reasonable, that is for the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) to decide.

Is ground rent part of the service charge?

No. Ground rent is rent payable to the landlord under the lease, not a payment for services, so it cannot be challenged as unreasonable in the way a service charge can. For most new long residential leases granted on or after 30 June 2022, the Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022 limits ground rent to a peppercorn.

Next steps

Most service charge disputes are won or lost on the lease and the evidence. Start with a clear written request for information, focus on specific items and keep paying the undisputed sums while you challenge the rest. With stronger information and costs rights arriving from 1 April 2027, leaseholders will be in a better position than at any time before, but the existing rights are already effective when used properly. We act for leaseholders, resident management companies and landlords, so we understand how these cases look from each side.

If you want to challenge your service charges, or you are a landlord facing a challenge, speak to our leasehold disputes solicitors. Call us on +44 207 566 1188 or email info@gurvelegal.com.