There are two ways to extend the lease of a flat in England and Wales. The first is the statutory route under the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993, which gives a qualifying leaseholder the legal right to a new lease for the remaining term plus 90 years, at a peppercorn (zero) ground rent, for a premium set by a fixed valuation formula. The second is an informal (sometimes called voluntary) extension, which is simply whatever deal you and your landlord agree. If you are weighing up a statutory lease extension against an informal offer from your landlord, the right answer depends on the terms on the table, your timescale and how much protection you need.

This guide sets out how each route works as at November 2026, what has changed under the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 and the Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022, and the points we check before advising a leaseholder to accept or reject an informal offer.

The statutory route in brief

The statutory route is a formal claim. You (or, more sensibly, your solicitor) serve a notice under section 42 of the 1993 Act on the landlord, setting out your proposed premium and terms. The landlord must reply with a counter-notice by the date in your notice, which must be at least two months away. If you cannot agree the figures, either side can apply to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) to decide them. Our guide to serving a section 42 notice explains the notice itself in detail.

What you get under section 56 of the Act is fixed by law:

  • A new lease for the unexpired term of your existing lease plus 90 years.
  • A peppercorn ground rent for the whole of the new term, so any existing ground rent stops when the new lease is granted.
  • A premium calculated under Schedule 13 of the Act: the loss in value of the landlord’s interest, plus 50% of any marriage value, plus compensation in limited cases.
  • Otherwise, broadly the same terms as your existing lease, with only limited modifications permitted.

Since 31 January 2025 you no longer need to have owned the flat for two years before making a claim. That requirement was removed by section 27 of the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 (brought into force by SI 2025/57), so a buyer can now serve a notice from the day they complete. Plenty of articles online still mention the two-year rule, and it is out of date.

The informal route in brief

An informal lease extension is a private negotiation. There is no statutory form, no deadline and no tribunal. The landlord can offer any length of extension, ask any premium and propose changes to other lease terms, and you can accept, counter or walk away. Once agreed, the deal is documented either by a deed of variation of the existing lease or by the surrender of the old lease and the grant of a new one.

Informal deals are common and can work very well, particularly where the landlord is a reasonable investor, a council or housing association with a published policy, or the residents’ own freehold company. They tend to fall down where the landlord uses the flexibility of the informal route to extract terms the statutory route would never allow.

Statutory vs informal: side by side

PointStatutory route (1993 Act)Informal route
Length of extensionUnexpired term plus 90 yearsWhatever is agreed
Ground rentPeppercorn for the whole new termExisting rent can continue to the original expiry date; for new leases granted since 30 June 2022, the extra years must be at a peppercorn
PremiumSet by the Schedule 13 formula, decided by the tribunal if not agreedWhatever is agreed; can be above or below the statutory figure
Other lease termsLargely unchangedLandlord can propose changes
Landlord’s costsYou pay the landlord’s reasonable legal and valuation costs under section 60, not their tribunal costsNegotiable; no statutory cap
TimescaleFixed statutory steps; often several months, longer if the tribunal is neededCan be quicker, or can stall indefinitely
CertaintyA legal right the landlord cannot refuse if you qualifyNone until the deal is signed; the landlord can withdraw
Valuation date fixedYes, the date the section 42 notice is servedNo; the price can move while you negotiate

Ground rent: the issue that decides most cases

For years the main danger of an informal offer was a hidden increase in ground rent. Offers of “99 years added” often came with a ground rent that doubled every 10 or 25 years, which could make the flat difficult to mortgage and sell.

The position changed on 30 June 2022, when the Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022 came into force for most residential leases. Under section 6 of that Act, where an existing leaseholder takes a new long lease to replace a lease granted before that date, the rent for the remainder of the original term cannot be more than the rent the old lease would have charged, and the rent for the additional years must be a peppercorn. In practice that means a properly documented informal extension granted today should not be able to increase your ground rent.

That does not make informal offers ground-rent neutral. Two points still matter:

  • The existing rent carries on. If your current lease has a ground rent of £300 a year that doubles every 25 years, an informal extension can keep that rent and those increases running until the date your old lease would have ended. The statutory route removes it entirely from the date of the new lease.
  • The structure of the deal matters. The 2022 Act applies to the grant of a regulated lease. Landlords and their advisers do not always document an informal deal as a new lease, and anything unusual about the structure needs checking before you sign.

The Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill, introduced to Parliament on 19 November 2026, also proposes to cap ground rents on existing leases at £250 a year, falling to zero after 40 years. It is a Bill, not law, and could change before it is passed. Our article on the proposed £250 ground rent cap explains what is proposed and when it might apply. For now, it is not a reason to accept an informal offer that keeps a high ground rent in place.

When an informal offer can make sense

An informal extension is not automatically the worse option. It can be the better choice where:

  • The premium is fair. If the price offered is at or below what a specialist valuer expects the statutory premium to be, and the ground rent is already low or the landlord agrees to a peppercorn, there may be little to gain from a formal claim.
  • Speed matters and the landlord is organised. Some landlords complete informal extensions in a few weeks. The statutory route has built-in waiting periods.
  • You want a longer term. Some landlords, including many resident-owned freehold companies, will grant 999 years. The statutory route gives exactly 90 years on top of the existing term.
  • You own a share of the freehold. Extensions between co-owners of the freehold are usually agreed informally, often at a nominal premium. Our guide to extending a lease when you own a share of the freehold covers how this is usually handled.

When the statutory route is usually safer

  • The landlord is proposing to keep a high or escalating ground rent.
  • The premium asked is well above your valuer’s statutory figure.
  • The landlord wants to change other terms, such as adding new restrictions, increasing service charge rights or charging new fees for consents.
  • The lease is approaching 80 years, so delay will push you into paying marriage value. Our guide to why the 80-year mark matters explains why.
  • You are selling. A section 42 notice can be assigned to your buyer, so the buyer takes over the claim. An informal offer is personal and cannot be passed on in the same way.
  • The landlord is slow, unresponsive or has a history of letting negotiations drift.

Costs on each route

On the statutory route you pay your own solicitor and valuer, plus the landlord’s reasonable costs of investigating your claim, valuing the flat and granting the new lease, as section 60 of the 1993 Act provides. You do not pay the landlord’s costs of any tribunal proceedings. On the informal route there is no statutory limit: the landlord can ask you to pay their costs as a condition of the deal, and some landlords charge an administration fee on top. The Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 contains provisions changing how costs are shared on statutory claims, but those provisions are not yet in force. For a full breakdown, see our guide to what a lease extension costs.

Starting informally, then switching

You do not have to pick one route forever. Many leaseholders open informal talks and keep the statutory route in reserve. The risk is time: until a section 42 notice is served, the valuation date is not fixed, so if your lease is shortening towards 80 years, or property values are rising, the premium can increase while you talk.

The opposite approach is also common. Serving a section 42 notice first fixes the valuation date and puts a statutory timetable in place, and the parties can still settle the terms by agreement at any point within that framework, without a tribunal hearing. Our step-by-step guide to the lease extension process shows how the timetable works once a notice has been served.

One trap to be aware of: if you serve a section 42 notice and then withdraw it, or let it lapse by missing a deadline, you cannot serve another notice for 12 months, and you will be liable for the landlord’s costs incurred up to that point. The 2024 Act removes this 12-month bar, but that provision is not yet in force.

What we check before you accept an informal offer

  1. The premium, compared with an independent valuation of the statutory premium from a surveyor experienced in 1993 Act valuations.
  2. The length of the new term and the date it runs from.
  3. The ground rent for the remainder of the original term and for the additional years, and whether the deal complies with the Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022.
  4. Every other proposed change to the lease, clause by clause.
  5. Who pays which costs, and whether any fee is payable if the deal falls through.
  6. Whether your mortgage lender’s consent is needed and whether the new terms will satisfy lenders when you come to sell or remortgage.
  7. Whether the landlord is the right party, with title to grant the extension, and whether any intermediate landlord or management company needs to be part of the deal.

Frequently asked questions

How do you do a statutory lease extension?

You start the claim by serving a section 42 notice on the landlord, setting out the premium you propose and the terms you want. Before serving it you need to confirm that you qualify, identify every landlord with an interest in the flat, and obtain a valuation from a surveyor who specialises in lease extensions. The landlord must reply with a counter-notice by the date in your notice, which must be at least two months away, and if terms cannot be agreed either side can apply to the First-tier Tribunal.

How much does it cost to extend a lease?

The main cost is the premium, which depends on the value of the flat, the ground rent and how long the lease has left, and rises significantly once the lease has 80 years or less to run because marriage value becomes payable. On top of the premium you pay your own solicitor and valuer and, on the statutory route, the landlord’s reasonable legal and valuation costs under section 60 of the 1993 Act. On the informal route the premium and costs are whatever you agree.

Can I extend my lease to 999 years?

Not under the statutory route as it stands, which adds 90 years to the existing term at a peppercorn ground rent. A landlord can agree a 999-year term informally, and many resident-owned freehold companies do. The 2024 Act provides for 990-year statutory extensions, but that change is not yet in force.

Which route is right for you?

If your landlord’s offer gives you a long term, a peppercorn or low fixed ground rent, no worse lease terms and a premium in line with the statutory valuation, an informal extension can be the quickest and cheapest way to deal with a short lease. If any of those points is missing, the statutory route gives you terms the landlord cannot refuse and a tribunal to settle the price. In many cases the best approach is to get a valuation first, so you know what the statutory premium is likely to be, and judge any informal offer against that figure.

We act for leaseholders and for landlords and freehold companies on both routes, which means we know how each side approaches the negotiation. If you would like us to review an offer or advise on a statutory lease extension claim, speak to our team. Where your building may be better served by buying the freehold, our leasehold and collective enfranchisement team can advise on that too. Call us on +44 207 566 1188 or email info@gurvelegal.com.